10 Cat Sitters in Old Bethpage, NY
Old Bethpage, NY
- Sort by
Every sitter on Meowtel is background-checked
Every sitter on Meowtel is background-checked
Kitty Caretaker
Kitty Caretaker
Kitty Caretaker
Emmie The Cat Whisperer
"Emmie did a great job as usual. This was my longest trip away since my cat was diagnosed with diabetes. She is great with sending videos and administering my senior cat his insulin. It's obvious my cats enjoy her visits."
— Steve, Jan 2026
Emmie The Cat Whisperer
"Emmie did a great job as usual. This was my longest trip away since my cat was diagnosed with diabetes. She is great with sending videos and administering my senior cat his insulin. It's obvious my cats enjoy her visits."
— Steve, Jan 2026
Emmie The Cat Whisperer
Lifelong Cat Lover Caring Sitter
Lifelong Cat Lover Caring Sitter
Lifelong Cat Lover Caring Sitter
Jazzy Paws Pet Care
"We have had many catsitters over the years -- some we felt were wonderful. Jazel stood out as better than them all. Truly. We have 2 cats; one is in end of life care. I had to travel on business for 5 days and was worried about leaving him with anyone. Jazel put my mind at ease on day one. She cared for him like I would and sent me videos. She has a keen eye for details and does things I didn't ask her to do. Example: During the recent snow, she not only dug her car out and braved the roads, but she brought a shovel and shoveled our stoop so she could open the front door. She is DEPENDABLE and takes her responsibility seriously. I can't say enough good things about Jazel. We will be using her again and again."
— Anne, Jan 2026
Jazzy Paws Pet Care
"We have had many catsitters over the years -- some we felt were wonderful. Jazel stood out as better than them all. Truly. We have 2 cats; one is in end of life care. I had to travel on business for 5 days and was worried about leaving him with anyone. Jazel put my mind at ease on day one. She cared for him like I would and sent me videos. She has a keen eye for details and does things I didn't ask her to do. Example: During the recent snow, she not only dug her car out and braved the roads, but she brought a shovel and shoveled our stoop so she could open the front door. She is DEPENDABLE and takes her responsibility seriously. I can't say enough good things about Jazel. We will be using her again and again."
— Anne, Jan 2026
Jazzy Paws Pet Care
Sabrina Supercatnanny
"Sabrina did a great job with my cats while we were away! She respected my shy cat’s boundaries but still made sure she was okay! She also gave plenty of attention to my other cat who loves pets! She was quick with updates and made sure to send pictures each day. We will definitely book Sabrina for our next trip!"
— Sarah, Sep 2025
Sabrina Supercatnanny
"Sabrina did a great job with my cats while we were away! She respected my shy cat’s boundaries but still made sure she was okay! She also gave plenty of attention to my other cat who loves pets! She was quick with updates and made sure to send pictures each day. We will definitely book Sabrina for our next trip!"
— Sarah, Sep 2025
Sabrina Supercatnanny
Reliable And Loving Cat Sitting
"Michael was great. He played with my kitties, sent photos and left the kitchen very clean"
— Laurie, Jan 2025
Reliable And Loving Cat Sitting
"Michael was great. He played with my kitties, sent photos and left the kitchen very clean"
— Laurie, Jan 2025
Reliable And Loving Cat Sitting
Trusted Care For Your Feline Family
"Hannah was wonderful with our cats. She arrived on time, listened carefully to everything we explained, and clearly cared about doing things right for them. We immediately felt comfortable leaving our fur babies in her care, which is not easy for us. Knowing she was there made our time away stress-free. We would absolutely book her again!"
— James, Mar 2026
Trusted Care For Your Feline Family
"Hannah was wonderful with our cats. She arrived on time, listened carefully to everything we explained, and clearly cared about doing things right for them. We immediately felt comfortable leaving our fur babies in her care, which is not easy for us. Knowing she was there made our time away stress-free. We would absolutely book her again!"
— James, Mar 2026
Trusted Care For Your Feline Family
Reliable Cat Sitter Drop-In Care
"John was absolutely AMAZING!! He was TRUSTWORTHY, respectful, nice, gave updates and pictures when he was there. I went away for 4 days and never had to worry about our cat. Our senior cat is very shy and timid around others but he came out for John. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️"
— James, Aug 2026
Reliable Cat Sitter Drop-In Care
"John was absolutely AMAZING!! He was TRUSTWORTHY, respectful, nice, gave updates and pictures when he was there. I went away for 4 days and never had to worry about our cat. Our senior cat is very shy and timid around others but he came out for John. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️"
— James, Aug 2026
Reliable Cat Sitter Drop-In Care
Dedicated Cat Caretaker
"This was my first time using a cat sitting service and I was pretty nervous trusting a stranger. That's why I am so thankful to have found Kaitlyn. From the first meet and greet to the end of her visits, Kaitlyn was communicative, responsible, and treated my furbaby Custard as if she was her own. It really gave us peace of mind knowing Custard was in great hands! Would give 10 stars if I could!"
— Madison, Jul 2026
Dedicated Cat Caretaker
"This was my first time using a cat sitting service and I was pretty nervous trusting a stranger. That's why I am so thankful to have found Kaitlyn. From the first meet and greet to the end of her visits, Kaitlyn was communicative, responsible, and treated my furbaby Custard as if she was her own. It really gave us peace of mind knowing Custard was in great hands! Would give 10 stars if I could!"
— Madison, Jul 2026
Dedicated Cat Caretaker
Cat Sitter-For All Ages Personalities
Cat Sitter-For All Ages Personalities
Cat Sitter-For All Ages Personalities
Oops!
We couldn't find any cat sitters. Please update your search filters or select a different location.