8 Cat Sitters servicing Oyster Bay, NY
Oyster Bay, NY
- Sort by
Every sitter on Meowtel is background-checked
Every sitter on Meowtel is background-checked
Reliable Cat Sitter Drop-In Care
Reliable Cat Sitter Drop-In Care
Reliable Cat Sitter Drop-In Care
Vet Student And Certified Fear Free
Vet Student And Certified Fear Free
Vet Student And Certified Fear Free
Emmie The Cat Whisperer
"Emmie did a great job as usual. This was my longest trip away since my cat was diagnosed with diabetes. She is great with sending videos and administering my senior cat his insulin. It's obvious my cats enjoy her visits."
— Steve, Jan 2026
Emmie The Cat Whisperer
"Emmie did a great job as usual. This was my longest trip away since my cat was diagnosed with diabetes. She is great with sending videos and administering my senior cat his insulin. It's obvious my cats enjoy her visits."
— Steve, Jan 2026
Emmie The Cat Whisperer
Beth Petz
"Elizabeth is the best! That’s all you need to know, but I shall not gatekeep her glory! Elizabeth just cat sat for me for 10 days (45 min sessions) while I was on vacation in Hawaii, an 11-hour flight from where I live. I had never used a cat sitter before—as in, I have never left my cat Rune alone for more than a DAY, so you can imagine how skeptical and scared I was. I decided to give Meowtel a chance over Rover because I read online that Meowtel vets their cat sitters much more extensively, and I was really nervous at the prospect of allowing a stranger into my home while I was away. I’m SO GLAD I decided to trust my gut and try it, because I truly could not have asked for a better experience than the one I had with Elizabeth. I was so impressed with her. Elizabeth got in contact with me quickly after booking and asked thorough, thoughtful questions leading up to our reservation (and took her OWN notes!). It’s clear to me that she truly cares about what she does, and has extensive experience with cats, because she knows how to interact with them in a way that respects their boundaries and keeps them calm yet curious. She asks all the right questions. She is kind, calm, professional, soft spoken, follows directions to a T, she’s an excellent communicator (she told me every day what time she expected to stop by and provided photos/videos/summaries every single day), and she was so incredibly respectful of my space and things (she left everything exactly as I had it and even asked if I have any house rules and if she should take off her shoes which I thought was so sweet of her). More than experience alone though, I think she truly has a gift with feline friends. My kitty took a liking to her right away, and he normally hides under the bed and doesn’t trust strangers. Not so with Elizabeth - he saw something good in her and bravely came mosying up to her from day 1, and by day 2 he was playing and making biscuits on her! Elizabeth is the kind of person who you can tell just has good cat energy/spirit, and animals can tell too. She even still visited my kitty during a 2-day snowstorm! My flight home was also delayed and there was a possibility I would need to extend my reservation and have her come an extra day, and she said it would be absolutely no problem. I can’t tell you how much that flexibility meant to me, knowing that if need be, I wouldn’t need to book with another stranger for a day or have my kitty get to know somebody else again. She spent every day checking for all the things I asked her to, playing with my kitty, giving him treats, and most of all giving him love, enrichment, and human interaction. I can’t recommend her enough. From one neurotic and overly-attached (but is there really such a thing?) cat mom to another, if you’re reading this, this is exactly who you want - you will not regret booking with Elizabeth one bit. It’s not easy being away from your pets but she will erase all anxiety and you’ll feel so much better knowing that your kitty is in the best care possible in the meantime. I will definitely be booking with her again in the future, and I know my kitty already can’t wait to see her again (I think he is seriously in love)!😻"
— Nicole, Feb 2026
Beth Petz
"Elizabeth is the best! That’s all you need to know, but I shall not gatekeep her glory! Elizabeth just cat sat for me for 10 days (45 min sessions) while I was on vacation in Hawaii, an 11-hour flight from where I live. I had never used a cat sitter before—as in, I have never left my cat Rune alone for more than a DAY, so you can imagine how skeptical and scared I was. I decided to give Meowtel a chance over Rover because I read online that Meowtel vets their cat sitters much more extensively, and I was really nervous at the prospect of allowing a stranger into my home while I was away. I’m SO GLAD I decided to trust my gut and try it, because I truly could not have asked for a better experience than the one I had with Elizabeth. I was so impressed with her. Elizabeth got in contact with me quickly after booking and asked thorough, thoughtful questions leading up to our reservation (and took her OWN notes!). It’s clear to me that she truly cares about what she does, and has extensive experience with cats, because she knows how to interact with them in a way that respects their boundaries and keeps them calm yet curious. She asks all the right questions. She is kind, calm, professional, soft spoken, follows directions to a T, she’s an excellent communicator (she told me every day what time she expected to stop by and provided photos/videos/summaries every single day), and she was so incredibly respectful of my space and things (she left everything exactly as I had it and even asked if I have any house rules and if she should take off her shoes which I thought was so sweet of her). More than experience alone though, I think she truly has a gift with feline friends. My kitty took a liking to her right away, and he normally hides under the bed and doesn’t trust strangers. Not so with Elizabeth - he saw something good in her and bravely came mosying up to her from day 1, and by day 2 he was playing and making biscuits on her! Elizabeth is the kind of person who you can tell just has good cat energy/spirit, and animals can tell too. She even still visited my kitty during a 2-day snowstorm! My flight home was also delayed and there was a possibility I would need to extend my reservation and have her come an extra day, and she said it would be absolutely no problem. I can’t tell you how much that flexibility meant to me, knowing that if need be, I wouldn’t need to book with another stranger for a day or have my kitty get to know somebody else again. She spent every day checking for all the things I asked her to, playing with my kitty, giving him treats, and most of all giving him love, enrichment, and human interaction. I can’t recommend her enough. From one neurotic and overly-attached (but is there really such a thing?) cat mom to another, if you’re reading this, this is exactly who you want - you will not regret booking with Elizabeth one bit. It’s not easy being away from your pets but she will erase all anxiety and you’ll feel so much better knowing that your kitty is in the best care possible in the meantime. I will definitely be booking with her again in the future, and I know my kitty already can’t wait to see her again (I think he is seriously in love)!😻"
— Nicole, Feb 2026
Beth Petz
Dedicated Cat Caretaker
"She was an excellent cat sitter: reliable, attentive, and clearly experienced with different cat personalities. She was always punctual and followed all instructions carefully. I have two cats with very different temperaments: one very social and one quite shy. She did a great job balancing their needs, spending quality time engaging with my social cat while also being patient and respectful of my shy cat, giving her the space to approach on her own terms. I also appreciated that she consistently made sure both cats were safely indoors before leaving. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a thoughtful and trustworthy pet sitter."
— Grace, Apr 2026
Dedicated Cat Caretaker
"She was an excellent cat sitter: reliable, attentive, and clearly experienced with different cat personalities. She was always punctual and followed all instructions carefully. I have two cats with very different temperaments: one very social and one quite shy. She did a great job balancing their needs, spending quality time engaging with my social cat while also being patient and respectful of my shy cat, giving her the space to approach on her own terms. I also appreciated that she consistently made sure both cats were safely indoors before leaving. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a thoughtful and trustworthy pet sitter."
— Grace, Apr 2026
Dedicated Cat Caretaker
Certified Cat Lover Medication Admin
"I couldn't be happier with Amanda. She was attentive, responsive, and very empathetic to my cats' needs, especially my diabetic guy, as well as to his owner's OCD requests. This was my first long trip since my cat was diagnosed with diabetes and Amanda totally reduced my anxiety (and handled the insulin shots no problem). I can't recommend her highly enough."
— Steve, Apr 2026
Certified Cat Lover Medication Admin
"I couldn't be happier with Amanda. She was attentive, responsive, and very empathetic to my cats' needs, especially my diabetic guy, as well as to his owner's OCD requests. This was my first long trip since my cat was diagnosed with diabetes and Amanda totally reduced my anxiety (and handled the insulin shots no problem). I can't recommend her highly enough."
— Steve, Apr 2026
Certified Cat Lover Medication Admin
Radyson
Radyson
Radyson
Ali Cat Care
"Our family just got home from a 10-day trip to Italy. It was our biggest trip yet. We were nervous to leave our cat alone and home empty for so long. So we made the decision to book Alex for overnights, and I’m so glad we did!! In the past, I’ve had cats get mad and stressed when we’ve been away-peeing in closets and on our beds. Well this was the exact opposite!! Lulu was 100% happy and stress free, our home was well taken care of, and we had peace of mind during our vacation with Alex’s updates. We can’t recommend Alex enough! We trust her completely and are so glad to have found her through Meowtel."
— Elizabeth, Apr 2026
Ali Cat Care
"Our family just got home from a 10-day trip to Italy. It was our biggest trip yet. We were nervous to leave our cat alone and home empty for so long. So we made the decision to book Alex for overnights, and I’m so glad we did!! In the past, I’ve had cats get mad and stressed when we’ve been away-peeing in closets and on our beds. Well this was the exact opposite!! Lulu was 100% happy and stress free, our home was well taken care of, and we had peace of mind during our vacation with Alex’s updates. We can’t recommend Alex enough! We trust her completely and are so glad to have found her through Meowtel."
— Elizabeth, Apr 2026
Ali Cat Care
Oops!
We couldn't find any cat sitters. Please update your search filters or select a different location.