I'm Kaitlyn

Dedicated Cat Caretaker

5.00
10 Reviews
2 Repeat clients
Background-checked
Background-checked
10+ Meowtel reservations completed
10+ Meowtel reservations completed
Catographer
Catographer
Neighborhood Explorer
Neighborhood Explorer
Active in the last week
Active in the last week
Background Checked

Book With Confidence

Meowtel provides customer support 365 days a year to help cat parents feel informed and supported at every step - including before a reservation is made.

In-home cat sitting visits typically include:

Litter box cleaning
Feeding
Water refresh
A text update with at least 1 photo
Playtime and belly rubs

Kaitlyn is experienced with 4 types of medications

Topical Ointments Eye/Ear Drops Oral Medication / Pills Inhalers

Check if Kaitlyn services your area

Good news! Kaitlyn covers your area.

Unfortunately, Kaitlyn does not cover your area right meow.


Dedicated Cat Caretaker

I'm Kaitlyn

Cat Sitting in Bay Shore, NY

I am a truly dedicated and compassionate animal lover with extensive experience caring for cats of all personalities and needs. Having personally cared for over 40 cats within the last five years and working at a cat sanctuary with over 300 residents, I’ve developed a deep understanding of feline behavior, body language, and emotional cues. I am highly attentive to each cat’s unique temperament and always adjust my care to ensure they feel comfortable, safe, and loved... I am a truly dedicated and compassionate animal lover with extensive experience caring for cats of all personalities and needs. Having personally cared for over 40 cats within the last five years and working at a cat sanctuary with over 300 residents, I’ve developed a deep understanding of feline behavior, body language, and emotional cues. I am highly attentive to each cat’s unique temperament and always adjust my care to ensure they feel comfortable, safe, and loved.
I genuinely enjoy spending quality time with cats, offering plenty of attention, affection, and enrichment tailored to their preferences; whether that means playtime, quiet companionship, or simply giving them space when needed. I am detail-oriented, reliable, and I take pride in carefully following all instructions regarding feeding, medication, routines, and special care requirements.
My top priority is always your cat’s safety, happiness, and overall well-being. You can trust that your pet will be treated with the same level of care and love as if they were my own.

Learn More About Kaitlyn

What is your typical process for working with a new cat parent?

When working with a new cat parent, I prioritize clear communication and expectation setting. I begin with a “meet-and-greet” to learn about your cat’s personality, routine, and specific care needs. This includes feeding schedules, favorite toys, hiding spots, medical needs, and any behavioral quirks. I take detailed notes and ensure I fully understand your instructions and expectations. During my visits, I stick closely to your cat’s routine to create a sense of comfort and stability. I pay close attention to body language and behavior, adjusting my approach to match their mood—whether they want affection, playtime, or space. I provide regular updates with messages and photos so you feel connected and reassured while you’re away. My goal is to build trust and ensure your cat feels safe, comfortable, and well cared for at all times.

How do you ensure the safety & security of the cats and the home while cat sitting?

Ensuring the safety and security of every cat in my care is my top priority. At the start of each assignment, I take time to thoroughly assess the home environment, identifying any potential risks such as unsecured windows, hazardous objects, or areas a cat could access that may not be safe. I make sure all entry points are properly closed and secured at every visit to prevent escapes. I follow all care instructions closely, including feeding routines, medication, and any specific safety guidelines provided. I remain observant of each cat’s behavior and physical condition, quickly noting any changes that could indicate stress or health concerns. I also move calmly and respectfully within the home to avoid causing unnecessary stress. Before leaving, I double-check that everything is secure and in place. My careful, detail-oriented approach ensures your cat remains safe, comfortable, and well cared for at all times.

How do you handle cats that are particularly timid or anxious?

When caring for anxious cats, I take a calm, patient, and gentle approach to help them feel safe and secure. I understand that every cat handles stress differently, so I start by giving them space and allowing them to approach me on their own terms. I avoid sudden movements or loud noises and keep my presence quiet and reassuring. I pay close attention to their body language and behavioral cues, adjusting my approach based on how they’re feeling. If a cat prefers to hide, I respect that while still ensuring they have everything they need, like food, water, and a clean litter box nearby. Over time, I build trust through consistency, soft communication, and positive interactions like gentle play or offering treats (if approved). My goal is never to force interaction, but to create a calm environment where the cat can relax and feel comfortable at their own pace.


Medication Experience:

Topical Ointments Eye/Ear Drops Oral Medication / Pills Inhalers

Skills:

Foster Parent T-N-R Shelter Volunteer

5.00
10 reviews
5.0
Attention to Detail
5.0
Communication
5.0
Tidiness
Madison

Madison

July 18, 2026

This was my first time using a cat sitting service and I was pretty nervous trusting a stranger. That's why I am so thankful to have found Kaitlyn. From the first meet and greet to the end of her visits, Kaitlyn was communicative, responsible, and treated my furbaby Custard as if she was her own. It really gave us peace of mind knowing Custard was in great hands! Would give 10 stars if I could!

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with twice per day visits
Alyson

Alyson

This month

This is our third time using Kaitlyn and will definitely not be our last! She’s reliable, communicative, kind, and above all else, so sweet to our cat. Highly recommend her!

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with drop-in visits
Alyson

Alyson

August 2, 2026

Kaitlyn was responsive, kind, and incredibly flexible to what we needed during our week away. She took good care of our little lady and we felt very comfortable with her (as did the cat!) We highly recommend and will definitely be booking with her in the future.

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with drop-in visits
Diana

Diana

June 1, 2026

Kaitlyn was wonderful with my cat Bella. She gave me updates on Bella on her visits. She let me know how my cat was doing. This gave me peace of mind on my vacation. I will definitely use Kaitlyn again.

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with drop-in visits
Nancy

Nancy

August 6, 2026

Meowtel-verified reservation with drop-in visits
Gabrielle

Gabrielle

June 7, 2026

Meowtel-verified reservation with drop-in visits

Service Area & Availability

Drop in visits rates

$25.00 / 20min
$40.00 / 45min
$54.00 / 60min

Overnight stay rate

$85.00 / Overnight

Kaitlyn's is 15%

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
Overnight Availability
Kaitlyn's Holiday Surcharge Applies
Service Area Map

Drop in visits rates

$29.00 / 20min
$44.50 / 45min
$58.50 / 60min

Overnight stay rate

$85.00 / Overnight

Kaitlyn's is 15%

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
Overnight Availability
Kaitlyn's Holiday Surcharge Applies
Service Area Map

Communicate & Pay Through Meowtel

Using Meowtel's messaging and payment tools helps keep booking details in one place and gives you access to platform support if you need help.

4.8
Rating on
Google
4.9
Reviews.io

325,000+
Reservations Completed

Trust & Safety

Every reservation is backed by the Meowtel Promise, giving you and your cat world-class customer support every step of the way.

If it doesn't feel like the right fit at the Meet & Greet, or if you have any concerns during the reservation, please call 1-844-MEOWTEL (1-844-636-9835) so we can help you re-book with another sitter.

Curious cat peeking over the banner

Veterans Day is coming up soon (November 11th, 2026)

Cat sitters on Meowtel are usually pretty busy, don't forget to book your sitter!

Book ahead, cat sitters on Meowtel fill up fast for the holidays!

Featured Cat Sitters Near Bay Shore, NY

  • Emily is a background-checked sitter in Islip who accepts new clients, offers overnight care, and is usually available on weekends and holidays. They also handle oral meds and topical ointments, while their gray tabby Kovu keeps the cat-love 🐾 flowing.

    Cat Care You Can Trust 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Emmie in West Babylon is a cat whisperer with 3 rescued kitties of her own, plus a gentle touch for shy cats. She accepts new clients, usually takes weekends and holidays, responds very fast, and knows oral meds, injections, and fluids 🐱

    Shy Cats Love Her 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Julie is a retired Registered Nurse and lifelong cat lover in North Babylon, NY, caring for shy or social cats with a calm touch. She accepts new clients, applies topical ointments, and brings insight from her cats, Meow Meow and Cupcake. 🐱

    Calm Care for Shy Cats 🐱
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Daisy, Sitter on Meowtel for 4+ years, welcomes new clients and brings holiday availability plus medication help for eye/ear drops and topical ointments. With detailed photo and video updates, 23 repeat clients trust her thoughtful drop-ins for their kitties 😺

    Trusted Cat Care, Holiday Ready 😺
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Jay in Patchogue is a background-checked sitter on Meowtel who welcomes new clients and responds very fast. They care for their own cats, Milo and Misha, while bringing topical, eye/ear, and oral medication skills to each visit. 🐾

    Fast, thoughtful cat care 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Hannah is a Sitter on Meowtel in Middle Island who accepts new clients, usually takes weekend requests, and offers overnight stays 🐱. Fast response plus medication skills, including injections and diabetic care, make them a strong fit for cats with special routines. They also share regular photo updates and know how to win over timid kitties like Remi.

    Medication-savvy cat care 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • John, a cat lover with Iggy at home, brings cat-sitting experience for family and friends plus medication skills with pills, eye/ear drops, and topical ointments. He welcomes new clients, shares updates and photos, and adapts to shy or social cats 😺

    Shy Cats Welcome 😺
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Kaitlyn is a background-checked sitter in Bay Shore who has cared for 40+ cats and works at a cat sanctuary with 300+ residents. She accepts new clients and offers overnight stays, plus medication help for pills, inhalers, and drops 🐱

    Trusted Cat Care, Tailored 🐱
    VIEW PROFILE

Frequently Asked Questions

Reservations officially begin at 12:00 AM in the sitter's time zone on the start date. Cat Parents may cancel within 24 hours of booking and receive a full refund, as long as the reservation has not yet started. After the first 24 hours, the following cancellation rules apply:


  • More than 48 hours before the reservation start date: Full refund. The sitter will not receive any earnings.
  • 24–48 hours before the reservation start date: 50% refund. The sitter will earn 50% of their planned earnings.
  • Within 24 hours of the reservation start date (or after it has begun): No refund. The sitter will earn 100% of their planned earnings.

All refunds are initially applied to the Cat Parent's Meowtel Account Balance for use toward a future reservation or tip. Funds may be returned to the original payment method at any time.

Meowtel is a marketplace that connects cat parents with independent sitters. For eligible reservations booked and paid for through Meowtel, the Meowtel Promise explains how we support cat parents if something unexpected comes up.

If it doesn't feel like a purrfect fit after a Meet & Greet or during a reservation, our support team is here to help at 1-844-Meowtel (1-844-636-9835). We'll take time to understand what happened and help you consider next steps, which could include help with a new reservation.

Bay Shore cat sitting rates will vary based on the sitter's experience and services, but the average price is $26.00. Prices depend on visit duration (20, 45, or 60 minutes) and whether you need drop-in visits or overnight stays.

Every cat sitter on Meowtel completes a background check. Ask your sitter about a Meet & Greet so you (and your kitties!) can feel comfortable with your sitter before you leave.

Cats are territorial animals and don't do well in new environments. The presence of other cats, dogs, and even birds in kennels or animal hotels cause an immense amount of stress. This is why Meowtel was created, so tailored in-home care is brought to you.

We recommend booking daily visits to keep your cats in their routine and help minimize feline anxiety while you're away.

Each visit typically includes: feeding, refreshing water bowls, litter box scooping, tidying up, medications, updates with photos, lots of playtime, and any special requests. Ask your sitter about a Meet & Greet!

5.00
10 reviews
5.00 From $25.00