12 Most Popular Cat Sitter in West Islip, NY - November, 2026
Maha is a Brooklyn sitter on Meowtel for 5+ years, with 47 repeat clients and fast replies. She shares life with Loki, her 11-year-old Maine Coon, and earns trust with detailed updates, medication help, and usually available weekends, holidays, and overnights 🐾
Emmie, the "cat whisperer" in West Babylon, brings gentle care to timid cats and seniors alike. With 3 rescued kitties at home, medication skills, and very fast responses, she welcomes new clients, usually takes holidays and weekends, and earns repeat trust 😺
Amanda is a new cat sitter in West Islip who cares for cats with different personalities, inspired by life with Cece and Olive. She offers topical ointments and eye/ear drops, welcomes new clients, and sends text/photo updates at your request 🐾
Michael in Deer Park brings a gentle touch to shy cats, with oral pill skills, experience caring for elderly cats, and a very fast response time. He accepts new clients, is usually available on weekends and holidays, and shares life with Laverne 🐱
Sabrina, a background-checked Sitter on Meowtel in Massapequa Park, NY, wins trust with fast responses, usually open weekends and holidays, and skills with oral meds, eye/ear drops, topical ointments, and injections. She shares life with Sterling and Shark 🐾
Central Islip cat lover Daisy brings 4+ years on Meowtel, accepts new clients, and is usually available on weekends and holidays. She handles topical ointments and eye/ear drops, shares photo updates, and has 24 repeat clients 😺
Jay brings a gentle touch to Patchogue cat care, with their own cats Milo and Misha inspiring a thoughtful approach. They accept new clients, respond very fast, and can help with oral medication, topical ointments, and eye or ear drops 🐱. Their reviews praise how they make shy cats feel at ease.
Kaitlyn is a background-checked sitter in Bay Shore who has cared for over 40 cats in the last five years and works at a sanctuary with 300+ residents. They handle oral meds, inhalers, and drops, offer overnight care, and welcome new clients 🐾
Hannah, a Middle Island sitter on Meowtel, brings a lifetime around cats and the calm care of a true cat person 🐱. She cares for Kiwi and Remi, welcomes new clients, offers overnight stays, and handles diabetes injections and anxiety medications with clear communication and fast replies.
Emily is a background-checked sitter in Islip who offers overnight stays, usually takes weekend and holiday bookings, and welcomes new clients with 10% off. She’s known for very fast replies, clear updates, and attentive care for cats like Kovu and Fern 🐾
John is a background-checked sitter in East Northport who accepts new clients and responds fast. He offers topical ointments, eye/ear drops, and oral meds, and he’s caring for his own cat, Iggy 🐾. He’s attentive to shy cats, too, and shares updates with photos.
Toni brings over 40 years of cat care and offers medication support, including injections and subcutaneous fluids. They welcome new clients in West Babylon, care for playful kittens to shy seniors, and have won over skittish cats in just one visit 🐱.
375,000+
Reservations completed
Meet & Greet
Available
Medication
Administration
225,000+
5-star reviews
Sitter rates start at $20 for 20 minutes of in-home cat sitting. Enjoy peace of mind with the Meowtel Promise.
Find and reserve your 5-Star cat sitter
Experience the magic of in-home hospitality. Cat sitters on Meowtel bring the purrfect hospitality to you.
SEARCH AND RESERVE
Search for your cat sitter and reserve drop-in visits or overnight stays.
MEET & GREET
The cat sitter may meet
you & the kitties to confirm it's a purrfect match.
TRAVEL EASY
Your cat sitter can provide regular updates, including lots of photos.
Cat Sitters Around West Islip, NY
Check Availability
What Cat Parents Say
More cat sitters near West Islip, NY
Meowtel's Purrfect Hospitality: The Meowtel Promise offers peace of mind with our world-class support and the Meowtel Guarantee