11 Most Popular Cat Sitter in West Islip, NY - October, 2026
Daisy in Central Islip brings 4+ years on Meowtel, 24 repeat clients, and a 5.00 rating to every visit. She accepts new clients, is usually available on weekends and holidays, and can help with eye/ear drops or topical ointments while sharing photo updates.
Emmie is a background-checked cat whisperer in West Babylon who cares for shy kitties with a gentle touch 😻 She accepts new clients, usually responds very fast, and is available on weekends and holidays. She also handles insulin and fluids with confidence.
Emily, a background-checked sitter in Islip, cares for cats with patience and clear updates. She offers overnight stays, usually takes holiday and weekend bookings, accepts new clients, and gives 10% off. With Kovu and Fern at home, she can give oral meds and topical ointments. 😺
In Deer Park, Michael cares for shy, anxious, and elderly cats with a gentle, cat-first approach 🐱. They give oral meds, welcome new clients, and are usually available on weekends and holidays. Their own senior kitty, Laverne, adds real-heart perspective.
Kaitlyn is a background-checked sitter in Bay Shore who has cared for over 40 cats in five years and works at a sanctuary with 300+ residents. She gives oral meds, inhalers, and eye drops, accepts new clients, offers overnight stays, and has 3 repeat clients. 🐱
Sabrina brings a cat-lover’s calm and detail to every visit in Massapequa Park, with Sterling and Shark inspiring her home-life insight. She handles injections, pills, and eye or ear drops, responds very fast, and usually takes new clients, weekends, and holidays 🐾
Jay, a Patchogue sitter, cares for Milo and Misha and welcomes new clients. Known for very fast response time, they bring oral, eye/ear drop, and topical medication skills, plus weekend availability for cats who love playtime, cuddles, and gentle care 🐾
Hannah cares for cats in Middle Island, NY with very fast responses and a patient, cat-first approach. She accepts new clients, offers overnight stays, and is usually available on weekends. Her skills include injections, oral meds, eye/ear drops, and topical ointments 🐱
Julie, a retired Registered Nurse and lifelong cat lover, brings a calm, patient touch to visits in North Babylon, NY. She’s good with shy or anxious cats, accepts new clients, and can help with topical ointments plus detailed updates 🐾
John cares for cats in East Northport with fast replies, accepts new clients, and handles topical ointments, eye/ear drops, and oral medication. He has cats his whole life, shares photo updates 📷, and understands shy kitties like Iggy.
Toni brings patient, gentle care to kittens and shy seniors alike, with 4 cats at home and 40+ years caring for cats. They accept new clients, are background-checked, and can give injections, fluids, pills, drops, and topical ointments. 🐱
375,000+
Reservations completed
Meet & Greet
Available
Medication
Administration
225,000+
5-star reviews
Sitter rates start at $20 for 20 minutes of in-home cat sitting. Enjoy peace of mind with the Meowtel Promise.
Find and reserve your 5-Star cat sitter
Experience the magic of in-home hospitality. Cat sitters on Meowtel bring the purrfect hospitality to you.
SEARCH AND RESERVE
Search for your cat sitter and reserve drop-in visits or overnight stays.
MEET & GREET
The cat sitter may meet
you & the kitties to confirm it's a purrfect match.
TRAVEL EASY
Your cat sitter can provide regular updates, including lots of photos.
Cat Sitters Around West Islip, NY
Check Availability
What Cat Parents Say
More cat sitters near West Islip, NY
Meowtel's Purrfect Hospitality: The Meowtel Promise offers peace of mind with our world-class support and the Meowtel Guarantee