Find a Trusted Cat Sitter in Old Bethpage, NY
Enter your zip code to find cat sitters nearby
245,000+
Reservations completed
Free
Meet & Greet
Medication
Administration
140,000+
5-star reviews
Our 10 Most Popular Cat Sitter in Old Bethpage, NY - November, 2025
With over 15 years of experience, this lifelong cat parent provides loving care and expert medication administration, ensuring safe and happy moments for your kitties. 🎉 They are also available for overnight stays!
With over 2 years of experience, this sitter offers loving care for your kitty, including medication expertise and overnight stays✨. Available on holidays and weekends to cater to your cat’s needs!
With 4+ years of purr-fect experience, Jazel is dedicated to putting your feline friends first! They provide expert care for pets needing medication, ensuring a cozy home vibe 🌟. Available on weekends!
Sabrina is a dedicated cat lover who has been a trusted sitter for over a year. With expert medication skills and experience with both kittens and seniors, they provide a safe and loving environment. Available on holidays! 🐾
Compassionate care awaits your kitties! With 3+ years of experience, they provide attentive visits full of playtime, detailed updates, and are available on weekends and holidays. Trust them for paw-sitive pet care! 🐾
With over a year of experience, this sitter excels in administering medications, special care, and is dedicated to understanding each cat's unique needs. They even bring exciting treats for extra joy! 🐾
Based in Rockaway Park, Bracha loves providing personalized care for your furry friend! With 5+ months experience, Bracha offers relaxed visits, playing and cuddling for happy kitties. 🐾💕
Maggie is a passionate cat lover with over 15 years of experience! 💖 Offering playful interactions and overnight stays, they ensure your fur baby feels safe and loved, even on holidays. Approved by shy cats!
With over 20 years of cat experience, they offer gentle care and love for your furry friends! Available on weekends and holidays, Emmie’s patience and tender approach create a stress-free space for all kitties. ❤️
Experience a caring companion for your cat! 🤗 With a passion for feline friends, they offer overnight stays and are often available on weekends. Personalized attention ensures your kitty feels loved!
Prices start at $20 for 20 minutes of in-home cat sitting that is backed by the Meowtel Promise, which includes insurance coverage and speedy support.
Find and reserve your 5-Star cat sitter
Experience the magic of our in-home hospitality. Our cat sitters bring the purrfect hospitality to you.
SEARCH AND RESERVE
Search for your cat sitter and reserve drop-in visits or overnight stays.
MEET & GREET
The cat sitter will meet
you & the kitties to ensure it's the purrfect match.
RELAX
You'll receive regular updates, including lots of photos.
Our Cat Sitters Around Old Bethpage, NY
Check Availability
What Our Cat Parents Say
More cat sitters near Old Bethpage, NY
Our Purrfect Hospitality Promise: Every first booking includes a free Meet & Greet and a100% satisfaction guarantee, because your cat deserves the best care.