Bethany truly did an amazing job with our shy kitties! We have five cats, one of them close to 18 years old, and all five warmed up to her by her final day of caring for them. Our senior cat is hyperthyroid and needs a pill twice a day, a supplement once a day, and also started an oral antibiotic days before our reservation - Bethany was great with all three types. We got updates and pictures during every visit, and it was a huge relief knowing our kitties were being looked after so we could enjoy our vacation. Thank you thank you! If I could give more than five stars, I would!!

it was our first time using Bethany, but won’t be our last. we were away for two weeks and, while gone, our old cat had a medical emergency. Bethany communicated throughout the entire event, took our cat to the vet after hours, helped us Face Time with the vet while on the middle of a cruise, and stayed with our cat until the very end (we decided to let her go). she also coordinated with the cremation company on our behalf since our phones weren’t working. I cannot recommend her enough…she truly went above and beyond without any hesitation or making us fee as though she was inconvenienced. she also took extra care with our remaining, shy cat to make sure he was ok afterwards. I’d give her a 20/10 if I could.

Our 5 cats always do well with Bethany & she puts up with the naughty stuff from the young ones. Her patience with geriatric care for my older ladies is always appreciated. The photos are so nice to receive, as they are all missed when we are away.

Bethany watched my cats for a long weekend and then for almost a week, and both times was wonderful - great communication, connected with my two very different personality cats, alerted me to a couple of house issues unrelated to my cats, sent awesome photos, and just all around was great!

I thought I already submitted this, but in case it didn't save... Bethany is wonderful. She understands cat behavior and took time to get to mine's individual personalities. She reached out for clarification on questions and sent me great updates and photos. I still missed them. But I knew they were in great hands.

Bethany helped out in a pinch, when plans changed & I needed a trusted sitter asap. Very reliable & responsive, along with understanding & accommodating special cat needs. She was also willing to help out with some unexpected home issues that occurred after I left town.

As always, Bethany is great with our high maintenance 5 cats. Great communication from start to finish, with photos provided from each visit, to comfort us while away from home.

Bethany was amazing! My cat Toothless truly loved her and enjoyed her company. Bethany sent me daily photos and updates which was super comforting while I was gone. I could not have asked for a better sitter! I highly recommend her and would use her services again in the future!

Bethany was great this was our second time having her sit for our kitties. They responded well to her and she sent great photos. she even noticed one of our kitties walking was off before we got home so we could get him scheduled with the vet. I love knowing that they are with someone I trust when we are out of town.

Bethany was phenomenal! Our Meet & Greet was so natural and welcoming. The kitties took to her very well as if they’ve known her forever. Bethany kept me updated very well with current photos and videos. She even went above and beyond to help fix my automatic litter robot when it was acting up. As my very first cat sitter, Bethany put my mind at ease with her professionalism, friendliness, and experience with cats. I will most definitely be working with Bethany again in the future!

Bethany is absolutely amazing! After meeting her, I immediately felt at ease. She was very thorough and asked thoughtful questions during our meet and greet. While on vacation, Bethany sent me updates for every visit and went above and beyond to put my shy kitties at ease. Plus, I loved the photos and video Bethany sent me. I knew they were in good, loving hands. I highly recommend her for taking care of your fur baby!

This was my first time using this app and Bethany was very prompt to requests and messages and sent us updates and photos while we were away. We really appreciate her and will definitely use her services again!

Bethany took great care of our Ruby while we were out of town for the weekend. Bethany was communicative, reliable, and friendly! I could tell Ruby felt comfortable and that meant so much to us.

I have a five cat household, their care and keeping is a lot! Bethany did a great job with all the instructions and kept them in their routine. I got daily photos and updates and the communication was fantastic! I was able to enjoy my vacation without worrying about my fur babies.

We have 4 cats, and they are all very shy. Bethany did a great job coaxing them out of their shells and we are so grateful we got to work with her.

My very shy cat loved Bethany right away. When she came to get the key he went right up to her and he followed her around while I showed her where everything is. I've never seen him take to a stranger like that. It made it easier to go out of town because I knew he would have company. She sent me pics, videos, and updates from their visits. I will definitely hire her anytime I need to leave town

Bethany did a great job, our cats were comfortable with her and her updates were fantastic.

Bethany was so sweet and attentive to my kitties! she was very quick to reply and sent pictures to ensure their happiness! they all very much enjoyed her presence

Bethany took amazing care of our cat during our week away. She provided thoughtful updates, photos, and videos every day, and it was clear she genuinely cared about him. Our cat quickly became comfortable with her! We came home to a happy, relaxed cat and would gladly book with her again. Highly recommended!

Bethany did a wonderful job with our cat and hiccups that come up along the way. we will use her again.

This is my second time working with Bethany and she's done an amazing job again. I really enjoy her taking care of my 2 cats. Bethany is the best cat sitter and I hope to work with her again soon!

Great experience with Bethany, communication was on point and had no worries while we were away even with a few cats that needed meds every day.

Bethany took great care of our Ruby once again! She was patient when Ruby was feeling a little shy, and sent many great photos!

Bethany was fantastic, AS ALWAYS!! We appreciate the ability to relax when traveling, knowing our kids are in good hands.

Everything went well with Bethany!

The cats were alive and happy. They seem to like her. The place was as expected. I will use Bethany again!

Bethany did a wonderful job for us and for our 3 cats!!

Bethany has spent the scheduled time with my guys for over a week now. She sends pictures and gives love to them. Everything seems to be going well... 2nd review to come in a day or so when vacation is done.

Bethany very responsive, understands cats, and understands my codependency on my cats!

She did an incredible job

Bethany was great and very attentive! Took great care of my cat!

Bethany was wonderful and very thorough. My cats loved her!

Bethany always goes above and beyond!

Great communication! Bethany took great care of my babies. I highly recommend her!

Bethany took great care of our two cats. It was fun to get daily updates. She was professional and responsive.

Bethany is wonderful!

Bethany is incredible every time! I never worry when my cats are with her!

Bethany always goes above and beyond for our kittens! truly so thankful to have her watch them!

Bethany took care of my shy kitties for 3 weeks! Updates were timely and i felt at ease the whole time!! thank you Bethany

Bethany is like a part of the family now! I feel so comfortable leaving our kittens with her! she gives the best updates and clearly cares for them like her own! she even helped take care of our outdoor plants while we were away!

Bethany took wonderful care of our cats. Her updates and photos were nice while were were away.

Bethany sent updates of our kitties throughout her sit! She charmed our shy kittens and took excellent care of them!

Bethany is excellent! She was available in a last minute situation, was a great communicator, and took perfect (purrfect?) care of Suzy!

Bethany is a cat sitter in the Columbus area. Their profile has been verified and their references have been checked by Meowtel.