Find a Loving Cat Sitter in Plainview, NY

Baldwin, NY cat lover Jazel cares for Luna, Nala, and Chrome, and helps shy cats like Cricket come out with slow, soft trust-building. Background-checked, very fast replies. Handles insulin shots, pills, drops, ointments, and subcutaneous fluids. Weekends and holidays welcome 🐾

Emmie in West Babylon, NY, is a cat whisperer with rescued Nugget, Nibbles, and Squeaky. Quiet, patient slow-blink care helps timid cats feel safe. Handles pills, drops, ointments, insulin injections, and subcutaneous fluids. Usually weekends/holidays, very fast replies, accepts new clients. 😻

Bay Shore, NY sitter Kaitlyn brings dedicated cat care with a meet-and-greet to learn routines, hiding spots, and medical needs. Background-checked and very fast to respond, they’ve cared for 40+ cats in five years, including a sanctuary (300+). Overnight visits, plus meds like pills, ointments, eye/ear drops, and inhalers. 🐱🐾

Sammi (Glen Cove, NY) is a vet student and Fear Free certified sitter who respects shy cats’ boundaries, keeps lights dim, and uses slow, gentle handling. With 2 cats on special diets and meds, Sammi is skilled with liquid medicine, pills, eye/ear drops, and topical ointments. Very fast replies, weekends welcome 🐾

Michael in Merrick, NY offers affectionate care with fast responses and Background-checked safety, plus overnight stays. Usually available on weekends and holidays, accepting new clients with 7 repeat clients. Plays with Baby girl, cares for Nabi, and administers pills, drops, ointments, injections, inhalers 🐱

Maggie, from Lynbrook/Rockville Centre area of Nassau County, brings a comforting and safe presence for shy cats. Cat owner to Claire and kitten Moonshadow, she plays, sends photo updates, and handles topical ointments plus eye/ear drops. Accepting new clients, loved by repeat families. 🐾

Massapequa Park cat lover Sabrina cares for bonded Sterling and Shark. With kitten and senior experience, plus licensed esthetician detail-focus and background-checked trust, she’s very fast to respond and usually available weekends, accepting new clients. Skilled with insulin shots, injections, drops, pills, and ointments, and does double check locking the door. 🔐

Amanda in Great Neck offers medication administration for pills, eye/ear drops, topical ointments, injections for diabetic management, and inhalers. With Sensi and Willow at home, a review notes they handled the insulin shots no problem. Very fast replies, accepts new clients, usually open weekends and holidays 🐱🐾

Rockaway Park sitter Bracha brings Low and Slow patience for shy cats, plus daily picture updates. Accepts new clients. Experienced with meds like eyedrops, oral pills, and subcutaneous fluids. Her own Sapphire and Teddy keep her cat care game sharp 🐱✨

Middle Island, NY cat sitter Hannah brings high-trust care for Kiwi and Remi, with comfort giving diabetes injections, anxiety meds, eye/ear drops, pills, and ointments. Background-checked, very fast replies, overnight + weekends + holiday visits, and accepts new clients 🐱

Abby in Melville, NY brings a cozy, patient approach, with comfortable with different personalities. Background-checked and accepting new clients, they can also help with eye/ear drops. With 2 cats of their own, they use string toys, calm ground-level chats, and slow blinking for timid kitties. 🐾

John in East Northport, NY offers attentive drop-in care for all kinds of cat personalities, including shy cats. Medication skills cover topical ointments, eye/ear drops, and oral pills, plus updates and photos. Accepting new clients. 🐾 Iggy loves wand play.