I'm Bethany

Calm Patient Cat Sitter

4.94
68 Reviews
< 15 mins Response Time
17 Repeat clients
Background-checked
Background-checked
50+ Meowtel reservations completed
50+ Meowtel reservations completed
Speedy Sitter/Quick Response Time
Speedy Sitter/Quick Response Time
Active Today
Active Today
Meowtel Sitter for 3+ years
Meowtel Sitter for 3+ years
Background Checked

Book With Confidence

Meowtel provides customer support 365 days a year to help cat parents feel informed and supported at every step - including before a reservation is made.

In-home cat sitting visits typically include:

Litter box cleaning
Feeding
Water refresh
A text update with at least 1 photo
Playtime and belly rubs

Bethany is experienced with 3 types of medications

Topical Ointments Eye/Ear Drops Oral Medication / Pills

Check if Bethany services your area

Good news! Bethany covers your area.

Unfortunately, Bethany does not cover your area right meow.


Calm Patient Cat Sitter

I'm Bethany

Cat Sitting in Columbus, OH

I am a cat lover and owned cats since I was just a child. I understand how to read a cats body language, knowing so much is told through their posture, their tail, and their ears. I am quiet and calm and am very good at earning trust from timid and standoffish kitties.
I thoroughly enjoy the company of cats and my current kitty, Raven,...
I am a cat lover and owned cats since I was just a child. I understand how to read a cats body language, knowing so much is told through their posture, their tail, and their ears. I am quiet and calm and am very good at earning trust from timid and standoffish kitties.
I thoroughly enjoy the company of cats and my current kitty, Raven, is 4 years old. Most of my cats were adopted.

I am self-employed with my own business, so I can make my own schedule as I decide. I am reliable, pay attention to details and believe in communication. So if you like someone who will reach out with any questions, keep you updated and overall just stay in touch... that's me!
🌈 friendly

Learn More About Bethany

What do you enjoy most about cat sitting?

I love learning each cat’s unique personality, likes and dislikes. After a few days together, they feel like extended family.

What advice would you give a customer looking to hire a cat sitter?

Just like your cats, each sitter’s personality is different. Find the sitter that best matches you and your cats. Some are high energy and great for rambunctious playful cats, others (like myself) are more calm and quiet and better with the more skittish, timid cats.

How do you ensure the safety & security of the cats and the home while cat sitting?

I always am very cautious when I first enter, to ensure no curious or anxious cats try to slip out the door as I enter. I lock the door when I enter. And I always watch that all doors are closed (or open), so no kitties get into unsafe places. I also watch for any toys or objects that a bored, playful cat might get hurt on while home alone. (Like string toys that they could get entangled in. I will wrap these up and tuck away, only pulling out to play with during my visit). I always confirm the door is safely locked again when leaving.

Are you usually available during holidays?

Most often I am. I dont mind popping over for a cat sit during a holiday.

How do you handle cats that are particularly timid or anxious?

I make sure I move calmly but also confidently through the house. No sudden movements or noises. (Including my phone, and the door when I enter). I will often sit on the floor in a clearly visible space, with my hands out, so the cat(s) can assess me and approach as they are comfortable. I also utilize the slow blink to slow I am safe. Very often, with this approach, I have been able to win over some very timid cats.


Medication Experience:

Topical Ointments Eye/Ear Drops Oral Medication / Pills

4.94
68 reviews
5.0
Attention to Detail
5.0
Communication
5.0
Tidiness
Allison

Allison

January 5, 2026

it was our first time using Bethany, but won’t be our last. we were away for two weeks and, while gone, our old cat had a medical emergency. Bethany communicated throughout the entire event, took our cat to the vet after hours, helped us Face Time with the vet while on the middle of a cruise, and stayed with our cat until the very end (we decided to let her go). she also coordinated with the cremation company on our behalf since our phones weren’t working. I cannot recommend her enough…she truly went above and beyond without any hesitation or making us fee as though she was inconvenienced. she also took extra care with our remaining, shy cat to make sure he was ok afterwards. I’d give her a 20/10 if I could.

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation 2+ weeks long
Catherine

Catherine

January 5, 2026

Bethany watched my cats for a long weekend and then for almost a week, and both times was wonderful - great communication, connected with my two very different personality cats, alerted me to a couple of house issues unrelated to my cats, sent awesome photos, and just all around was great!

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with twice per day visits
Kira

Kira

June 16, 2025

Bethany was great this was our second time having her sit for our kitties. They responded well to her and she sent great photos. she even noticed one of our kitties walking was off before we got home so we could get him scheduled with the vet. I love knowing that they are with someone I trust when we are out of town.

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with drop-in visits
Catherine

Catherine

December 24, 2025

I thought I already submitted this, but in case it didn't save... Bethany is wonderful. She understands cat behavior and took time to get to mine's individual personalities. She reached out for clarification on questions and sent me great updates and photos. I still missed them. But I knew they were in great hands.

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with twice per day visits
Anna

Anna

December 10, 2025

As always, Bethany is great with our high maintenance 5 cats. Great communication from start to finish, with photos provided from each visit, to comfort us while away from home.

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation with twice per day visits
Seetha

Seetha

December 17, 2025

Bethany was amazing! My cat Toothless truly loved her and enjoyed her company. Bethany sent me daily photos and updates which was super comforting while I was gone. I could not have asked for a better sitter! I highly recommend her and would use her services again in the future!

Read more
Meowtel-verified reservation 2+ weeks long

Service Area & Availability

Drop in visits rates

$26.00 / 20min
$42.00 / 45min
$55.00 / 60min

Bethany's is 20%

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
Overnight Availability
Bethany's Holiday Surcharge Applies
Service Area Map

Communicate & Pay Through Meowtel

Using Meowtel's messaging and payment tools helps keep booking details in one place and gives you access to platform support if you need help.

4.8
Rating on
Google
4.9
Reviews.io

300,000+
Reservations Completed

Trust & Safety

Every reservation is backed by the Meowtel Promise, giving you and your cat world-class customer support every step of the way.

If it doesn't feel like the right fit at the Meet & Greet, or if you have any concerns during the reservation, please call 1-844-MEOWTEL (1-844-636-9835) so we can help you re-book with another sitter.

Curious cat peeking over the banner

Memorial Day is coming up soon (May 25th, 2026)

Cat sitters on Meowtel are usually pretty busy, don't forget to book your sitter!

Book ahead, cat sitters on Meowtel fill up fast for the holidays!

Featured Cat Sitters Near Columbus, OH

  • Mattie is a dedicated cat lover who brings calm to timid kitties by matching their energy and respecting boundaries. Experienced with inhalers, they provide compassionate, patient care for cats of all temperaments while offering essential overnight stays. 😸🐱

    Patient comfort for your cat 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • With a passion for rescue cats and specialized experience in diabetic care, Melissa ensures your feline receives attentive love. She is an expert at soothing shy cats, making her a perfect choice for nervous kitties. You will receive plenty of updates and photos of your beloved fur babies. 🐱🐾

    Compassionate care for rescue cats 🐈
    VIEW PROFILE
  • With a decade of feline love, this sitter provides expert care, including insulin shots and oral medication. They are patient with shy rescues and offer reliable, retired-life dedication. 🐾🐱

    Trusted care for every cat 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • With over 25 years of cat owner experience, this dedicated sitter provides exceptional care. Highly skilled in administering medications including inhalers and fluids, they love to ensure shy cats feel comfortable. Available to help with visits on weekends! 🐾🐱

    Expert medical and belly rubs 😺
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Need a pro for shy kitties? Sitter on Meowtel for 2+ years, Bethany is a pro at earning trust through calm movements and slow blinks. She’s highly trusted for complex needs and dedicated to thorough check-ins, keeping your peace of mind a priority. 😻✨🌈

    Calm care for timid cats 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • With a lifetime of feline companionship and two energetic kitties of their own, this sitter provides expert care, including medication administration. Experience deep peace of mind with photo updates and attentive play sessions featuring wand toys, ensuring your furry friends feel happy and secure while you are away. 🐾🐱

    Loving care for your cats 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE
  • Sitter on Meowtel for 3+ years, Amie is skilled at providing oral medication and soothing shy cats. With 15 repeat clients and a passion for engaging playtime, their goal is to ensuring your pets feel safe and loved while you are away. 🐱✨

    Trusted and experienced cat care! 😺
    VIEW PROFILE
  • With a background in nurturing care, Lysin offers attentive visits tailored to comfort 🐾. By moving at your cat’s pace, they build genuine trust with even the shyest kitties. Their patient, gentle approach ensures a calm and reassuring experience for your beloved companions while you are away 🐱.

    Gentle care for timid cats 🐾
    VIEW PROFILE

Frequently Asked Questions

Reservations officially begin at 12:00 AM in the sitter's time zone on the start date. Cat Parents may cancel within 24 hours of booking and receive a full refund, as long as the reservation has not yet started. After the first 24 hours, the following cancellation rules apply:


  • More than 48 hours before the reservation start date: Full refund. The sitter will not receive any earnings.
  • 24–48 hours before the reservation start date: 50% refund. The sitter will earn 50% of their planned earnings.
  • Within 24 hours of the reservation start date (or after it has begun): No refund. The sitter will earn 100% of their planned earnings.

All refunds are initially applied to the Cat Parent's Meowtel Account Balance for use toward a future reservation or tip. Funds may be returned to the original payment method at any time.

Meowtel is a marketplace that connects cat parents with independent sitters. For eligible reservations booked and paid for through Meowtel, the Meowtel Promise explains how we support cat parents if something unexpected comes up.

If it doesn't feel like a purrfect fit after a Meet & Greet or during a reservation, our support team is here to help at 1-844-Meowtel (1-844-636-9835). We'll take time to understand what happened and help you consider next steps, which could include help with a new reservation.

Columbus cat sitting rates will vary based on the sitter's experience and services, but the average price is $24.00. Prices depend on visit duration (20, 45, or 60 minutes) and whether you need drop-in visits or overnight stays.

Every cat sitter on Meowtel completes a background check. Ask your sitter about a free Meet & Greet so you (and your kitties!) can feel comfortable with your sitter before you leave.

Cats are territorial animals and don't do well in new environments. The presence of other cats, dogs, and even birds in kennels or animal hotels cause an immense amount of stress. This is why Meowtel was created, so tailored in-home care is brought to you.

We recommend booking daily visits to keep your cats in their routine and help minimize feline anxiety while you're away.

Each visit typically includes: feeding, refreshing water bowls, litter box scooping, tidying up, medications, updates with photos, lots of playtime, and any special requests. Ask your sitter about a free Meet & Greet!

4.94
68 reviews
4.94
From $26.00

Free Cancellation (48+ hrs)