Our 17 Most Popular Cat Sitter in Garden City, NY - September, 2025
Harshita is a cat enthusiast with a calico named Subbu 🐾. They offer overnight stays and personalized care, ensuring your feline feels comfortable. Available on holidays and weekends for your convenience!
Isabel is a dedicated cat lover who treats every feline with extra care. With skills in administering medicine and lots of patience, they're here to ensure your cat stays happy and relaxed! 🐾😊
With 15+ years of experience, this lifelong cat lover skillfully cares for all kitties, especially those needing medication! They’ve rescued purr-fectly happy cats and provide tender, loving care 🐱
Meet a lifelong cat lover ready to care for your kitties! 💖 With experience in managing energetic and shy felines alike, they ensure your cat gets plenty of attention and proper care. Overnight stays available!
Anissa has 2 years of cat-sitting experience, having grown up with 12 cats! 🐱 They're skilled in handling cats of all personalities and offer overnight stays to keep your kitties cozy! Available on weekends, they provide the perfect care for your furry friends.
Experience gentle cat care with Mariah, who brings love and respect to each cat's personality. 🌟 They provide regular updates and embrace quiet companionship for your beloved fur baby. Safe and loved.
With deep love for cats ❤️, Josephine offers passionate care tailored to each cat’s needs. Experienced with medications and special care, easily adapts to your schedule—even for overnight stays!
Caring and experienced, they treat every kitty like their own! With over 20 years of cat companionship, they're available on weekends and holidays. Rest assured your fur baby will feel safe! 🐾
With over 3 years of experience, this sitter ensures your cats are well-loved and taken care of. They excel at administering medications 💊 and have a heartwarming connection with their own three cats! Compassionate and detail-oriented.
With over 3 years of experience, they provide loving care and administer medications, ensuring every cat feels at ease 🌟. Loves cats uniquely! Book a reliable sitter today!
With over 4 years of experience, Jazel is a trusted sitter ready to care for your feline friends. Skilled in administering medications, they provide detailed updates, ensuring your cats feel loved at home. 💖🐱
With over 2 years of caring for cats, they're experienced in medication and make sure your kitty feels comfortable during every visit. Available for overnight stays, they are here to keep your feline happy! 😺🌟
Experience calm and gentle care with this cat sitter who understands each cat's need for space and comfort. Expect detailed updates and 5+ adorable photos during every visit! 😺
Maggie brings over 15 years of cat love 🎉, excels in comforting shy kitties, and offers personalized care. Overnight stays available for extra coziness, especially on weekends and holidays! 🐾
Meet a dedicated cat sitter with 3+ years of experience! They provide loving care, enjoy overnight stays, and specialize in medicine administration, ensuring overall happiness for your feline friend! 🐱💖
Maya is a caring cat lover with 5+ months as a sitter! 🐾 They ensure comfort for all furry friends and are experienced in administering meds. Trustworthy care just for your cat!
With a passion for cats and extensive experience, this sitter offers a range of care from playtime to medication. Available on weekends and holidays, they provide a loving environment for your feline friends. 🐾
Prices start at $20 for 20 minutes of in-home cat sitting that is backed by the Meowtel Promise, which includes insurance coverage and speedy support.
Find and reserve your 5-Star cat sitter
Experience the magic of our in-home hospitality. Our cat sitters bring the purrfect hospitality to you.

SEARCH AND RESERVE
Search for your cat sitter and reserve drop-in visits or overnight stays.

MEET & GREET
The cat sitter will meet
you & the kitties to ensure it's the purrfect match.

RELAX
You'll receive regular updates, including lots of photos.
Our Cat Sitters Around Garden City, NY
Check Availability
What Our Cat Parents Say
More cat sitters near Garden City, NY
Our Purrfect Hospitality Promise: Every first booking includes a free Meet & Greet and a100% satisfaction guarantee, because your cat deserves the best care.