14 Most Popular Cat Sitter in Garden City, NY - November, 2026
Jazel, Sitter on Meowtel for 5+ years in Baldwin, is a Popular, background-checked cat lover with 31 repeat clients and a very fast response time 🐾 She cares for Luna, Nala, and Chrome, takes on medication needs, and usually accepts holidays. Her detailed updates help cat parents feel at ease.
Vivian is a very fast responder in Jackson Heights, trusted by 42 repeat clients and welcoming new cats. She offers overnight stays, weekend and holiday visits, and handles pills, injections, diabetic care, fluids, and eye or ear drops 😺
Sarah is a cat mom to Hanson, Scruffy, and Yoshi, and she brings that same care to every visit. With fast responses and overnight, weekend, and holiday availability, she also handles oral meds, eye and ear drops, topical ointments, and injections. 🐱
Winona is a cat person at heart in Long Beach, NY, with 2 tuxedo cats of her own and a background volunteering at animal shelters 🐱 She offers overnight stays, usually takes weekend and holiday bookings, and can help with oral meds, eye or ear drops, and topical ointments. She also responds very fast and welcomes new clients.
Elizabeth brings over a decade of experience caring for cats in the Bronx, with a patient, observant style that suits shy, energetic, and medically complex cats alike. She offers overnight stays, usually takes weekend and holiday bookings, welcomes new clients, and is skilled with pills, injections, inhalers, and more 😺
Michael is a background-checked sitter in Merrick who welcomes new clients, offers overnight stays, and usually takes holiday or weekend visits. They bring 2+ years of cat sitting, fast replies, and medication skill with pills, injections, and fluids 🐾
Eman brings rescue-savvy cat care from Jamaica, NY, with 3+ years on Meowtel, overnight stays, and usual holiday/weekend availability. A cat owner to Mayu, they’re trusted by 12 repeat clients and welcome new clients. 🐾
Anissa brings about 2 years of cat sitting in New York, plus care for senior cats, newborns, and kitties with separation anxiety. She accepts new clients, usually takes weekend and holiday bookings, and can give oral meds or topical ointments. Fast replies 🐾
Kaitlyn brings extensive experience from caring for over 40 cats in five years and working at a sanctuary with 300+ residents. She accepts new clients, offers overnight stays, and handles pills, inhalers, eye/ear drops, and topical ointments. 🐱
Sammi brings a Fear Free approach and a calm, cat-led style, shaped by clinical experience and life with Franklin and Lily 🐾. They’re comfortable with topical ointments and eye or ear drops, and they welcome new clients with extra care for timid or anxious cats.
Randy is a Brooklyn sitter with 5+ years caring for cats, including timid ones who need patience and space. They share life with Avery, their 12-year-old tabby, and accept new clients. Overnight stays, weekends, holidays, and medication help make them a strong fit 🐾
Shannon, a cat parent in New Hyde Park, offers attentive care with oral medication and topical ointment skills. They often have weekend availability, welcome new clients with 20% off, and bring hands-on comfort backed by their cat Tum Tum 🐱
Rebecca cares for cats with patience and gentleness, and her tabby girl Moon keeps her tuned in to shy or anxious kitties. She accepts new clients, is usually available during holidays, and can give oral meds or topical ointments. 🐱
Danielle brings calm, cat-savvy care in Farmingville, with overnight visits and new-client availability. She draws on lifelong cat care plus hands-on rescue work, including shy, senior, FIV+ cats, and can give pills, eye/ear drops, and ointments. 🐾
375,000+
Reservations completed
Meet & Greet
Available
Medication
Administration
225,000+
5-star reviews
Sitter rates start at $20 for 20 minutes of in-home cat sitting. Enjoy peace of mind with the Meowtel Promise.
Find and reserve your 5-Star cat sitter
Experience the magic of in-home hospitality. Cat sitters on Meowtel bring the purrfect hospitality to you.
SEARCH AND RESERVE
Search for your cat sitter and reserve drop-in visits or overnight stays.
MEET & GREET
The cat sitter may meet
you & the kitties to confirm it's a purrfect match.
TRAVEL EASY
Your cat sitter can provide regular updates, including lots of photos.
Cat Sitters Around Garden City, NY
Check Availability
What Cat Parents Say
More cat sitters near Garden City, NY
Meowtel's Purrfect Hospitality: The Meowtel Promise offers peace of mind with our world-class support and the Meowtel Guarantee